Should You Risk Signing A Pre-incorporation Contract?

Should You Risk Signing A Pre-incorporation Contract?

Commercial contract breaches can result in one party having to pay a vast sum of money to another, as compensation for the breach. The financial ramifications can affect not only the signatories, but other entities reliant upon them. As a result, there are many rules and regulations that govern the formation and enforceability of contracts. However, a pre-incorporation contract carries an additional layer of risk for the parties and should only be entered into following the receipt of experienced legal advice.

What is a pre-incorporation contract?

The law allows for individuals to limit their liability in commercial contracts by entering into the contracts on behalf of a company. However, there may be times when the founders / owners of a company need or desire to enter into a contract on behalf of that company, before it is even incorporated. This is known as a pre-incorporation contract.

What are the risks of entering a pre-incorporation contract?

The applicable legislation governing liability in a pre-incorporation contract is s.51 of the Companies Act 2006 (which replaced a corresponding provision, s.36C, in the Companies Act 1985).

It reads as follows:

51 Pre-incorporation contracts, deeds, and obligations

(1) A contract that purports to be made by or on behalf of a company at a time when the company has not been formed has effect, subject to any agreement to the contrary, as one made with the person purporting to act for the company or as agent for it, and he is personally liable on the contract accordingly.

The case of Royal Mail Estates v Maples Teesdale [2015] EWHC 1890 (Ch)[1] highlights the risks involved in entering into such a transaction. The case demonstrates why it is vital for anyone signing or entering into an agreement on behalf of a company to be sure that the subject company is validly incorporated and that it remains so before the agreement is entered into.

To put in perspective how easy it is to be caught out in a pre-incorporation contract, it is worth noting that the defendants, in this case, were a firm of solicitors.

The facts of Royal Mail Estates v Maples Teesdale

The case concerned the purchase of a commercial property by a company, before it had been incorporated. The contract was signed by a law firm on behalf of the company and featured a provision which stated that the “benefit of this contract is personal to the buyer.” The ‘buyer’ in the contract was the company.

At the time of the contract, the parties were unaware that the company had not been incorporated.

The Royal Mail Estates applied to enforce the contract, claiming that the defendants (the solicitors), who had purported to act as the company’s agents, were liable for performing the contract’s obligations.

The legal issue

The court had to rule on whether the wording, “benefit of this contract is personal to the buyer” was sufficient to be an “agreement to the contrary” under s. 51 of the Companies Act 2006.

The decision

There is a presumption in English law that agreements entered into by commercial parties are intended to be legally binding.

At the time of the contract, the Companies Act 1985 was the applicable legislation and was therefore relied upon by the High Court.

Judge Klein of the High Court took a restrictive approach to the interpretation of s. 36C. He stated that for an “agreement to the contrary” to apply, the parties to the agreement had to have s.36C in mind when drafting, deliberately constructing wording to exclude s.36(C)(1).

The fact that neither party was aware the company was not yet incorporated meant they could not have had s.36C in mind when drafting and agreeing to the contract. The actual intention of the wording in question was more likely to prevent or restrict a third party from becoming a third-party purchaser by way of assignment or sub-sale in circumstances where the original contracting party was the company.

What this decision means for those considering entering a pre-incorporation contract

Those entering into a pre-incorporation contract need to be aware that the threshold for being covered by the exclusion phrase “any agreement to the contrary,” under s.51 of the Companies Act 2006 (section 36(C)(1) of the 1985 Act), is high.

Without properly excluding s. 51, the agents / signatories who are acting on behalf of a company, can risk being personally liable for any obligations.

It is crucial to obtain legal advice, which should include the solicitor checking to see if the company purporting to enter the agreement has in fact been incorporated.

If you are planning to engage in a pre-incorporation contract, Royal Mail Estates v Maples Teesdale makes it clear that s.51 must be in the minds of the parties when drafting words to exclude liability. This needs to be made unambiguous in any agreement entered into.


Saracens Solicitors is a multi-service law firm based opposite Marble Arch on the North side of Hyde Park in London. We have years of experience advising on commercial and company law matters. For more information, please call our office on 020 3588 3500.

[1] http://freecases.eu/Doc/CourtAct/4713059

Continue Reading

Setting Up a Limited Company: What Companies House Won’t Tell You (Articles, Share Structure, Founders’ Agreements)

Written by Fraz Butt, Senior Director · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 4 November 2026   You can register a limited company online in an afternoon. Fill in a form, pay the fee, tick a few boxes and you’ll usually have a certificate of incorporation within a day or so. It’s never been easier, and honestly, […]

Share Purchase Agreements Explained: Key Clauses, Warranties & Indemnities

Written by Fraz Butt, Senior Director · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 02 November 2026   If you are buying or selling a limited company, there is one document that will matter more than any other: the share purchase agreement, or SPA. It sets the price, decides who carries which risks and, if something goes wrong […]

Section 172 Companies Act 2006 Explained: A Practical Guide to Directors’ Duties

Written by Marcia Howards, Senior Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 29 October 2026   Whether you are the director of a start-up, a family-owned business or an established company, understanding your legal duties is essential. One of the most important obligations imposed on company directors is contained within Section 172 of the Companies […]

Franchising: UK Franchising in the QSR sector

Written by Marcia Howards, Senior Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 12 October 2026   Entering the UK’s Quick Service Restaurant (QSR) sector puts you in the most dynamic segment of British hospitality. Valued at over £14 billion, the UK fast-food market is actively expanding, driven by massive consumer demand for convenience, speed, and […]

Written Resolutions UK: Company Law Guide for Directors

Written by Fraz Butt, Senior Director · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 7 October 2026   A written resolution lets the shareholders of a private limited company make a formal decision without holding a general meeting. Under section 281 of the Companies Act 2006, it is passed once shareholders holding the required share of voting rights […]

Unfair Prejudice Petitions: Why There’s No Time Limit to Bring a Claim

Written by Maxim Sealey, Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 24 September 2026   Unfair prejudice petitions are unusual in English litigation because there is no statutory limitation period restricting when a shareholder can bring one, unlike almost every other civil claim, which must generally be issued within a fixed number of years of […]

Business Startup Legal Guide: Structure, Contracts & Growth for UK Founders

Written by Fraz Butt, Senior Director · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 8 September 2026   This startup legal guide covers the decisions that matter most as you build a business in the UK: choosing the right company structure, agreeing ownership with any co-founders, putting proper contracts in place, hiring your first employees, raising investment, and […]

Trademarks, Copyright & IP: A Founder’s Guide to Protecting Your Business

Written by Fraz Butt, Senior Director · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 8 September 2026   Protecting your intellectual property means registering trademarks for your brand name and logo, understanding that copyright in original work arises automatically without registration, and knowing what steps to take if a competitor copies your work. Your brand name, logo, product […]

Employment Contracts for Your First Hires: Getting It Right From Day One

Written by Fraz Butt, Senior Director · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 8 September 2026   Before hiring your first employee at your startup business, a founder needs a written contract of employment, a small number of core policies, and an understanding of statutory obligations such as pension auto enrolment and the right to work checks. […]

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

Name