Carillion Collapse – How The Failure Of A Large Company Affects Other Businesses

Carillion Collapse – How The Failure Of A Large Company Affects Other Businesses

The collapse of the outsourcing giant, Carillion, is the second big business failure, following Monarch Airlines, which has impacted thousands of employees, customers, and suppliers in the last three months[1].

Latest estimates state around 30,000 businesses are owed around £1 billion in unpaid costs, and many are expected to go under themselves due to being unable to bear the cost of never being paid[2]. Banks may also face around £2 billion of losses and 43,000 workers, (19,500 of whom are in the UK) face an uncertain future.

The fact Carillion went into liquidation (whereby a liquidator tries to realise any assets distribute as much as possible to creditors), as opposed to administration (whereby the company continues to operate while a buyer is found for viable parts of the organisation), illustrates the depth of the construction giant’s problems. It is estimated it only had £29 million in cash when it collapsed, and the decision to liquidate means there was no part of the company worth buying.

The effect of a giant such as Carillion collapsing is catastrophic. There was talk that the UK government, which outsources many contracts to the failed organisation, would not allow Carillion to go under as it was “too big to fail”. However, Ministers made the decision that taxpayers could not be asked to bail out the stricken private company.

The question on many lips is “what are the rights of suppliers and contractors when a company falls into liquidation?” Are they doomed to go down as well, or is legal redress available?

The Insolvency Act 1986 and the position of unsecured creditors

Suppliers of large organisations who go into liquidation are often incredibly vulnerable. Andy Bradley of Flora-Tec was forced to lay off ten staff the day after Carilion made its announcement, illustrating the disastrous “domino effect” the failure of such a large organisation can have[3]. Flora-tec is owed around £800,000 by Carillion for providing ground services work to schools and hospitals. This figure represents around 10% of Flora-tec’s annual turnover.

The UK government, which has been criticised for still providing contracts to Carillion despite three profit warnings, told small firms who worked for the construction giant on private sector contracts that they would only receive two days of government support[4]. In addition, Carillion was reported to have extended its payment terms to suppliers in 2016, meaning many outstanding invoices are months old.

Hauntingly, trade body ‘Build UK’ told the BBC that in the past, when other big contractors have failed, around 18% of businesses who were creditors did not survive the next five years[5].

The Insolvency Act 1986 states who gets paid first when a company goes into liquidation. The hierarchy is as follows:

  • Liquidator fees and expenses
  • Secured creditors with a fixed charge
  • Preferential creditors
  • Secured creditors with a floating charge
  • Unsecured creditors
  • Connected unsecured creditors
  • Shareholders

Suppliers are usually unsecured creditors; therefore, often end up with little or nothing after everyone above them gets paid.

You may be thinking the best way to get around the hierarchy is to sue for breach of contract. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to bring legal action against an insolvent company. The Insolvency Act, section 130 limits any claims or actions against an insolvent company by virtue of a statutory stay of proceedings. The stay means that no action or proceedings can be brought, or continued with, against the company without the leave of the court.

What factors will the court take into account when considering whether to lift a stay of proceedings in an insolvency situation?

The purpose of a liquidation stay is to ensure that all creditors of an insolvent company are treated equally and no one “jumps the queue”. It acts to prevent any of the organisation’s assets being dispersed following litigation and prevents the liquidator having to appear in proceedings when the matter can be dealt with effectively via the liquidation process.

A creditor can make an application to have the stay lifted. The main concern the court will have when considering such an application is whether one creditor will obtain an advantage, or the liquidation process will be interrupted.

It is imperative that you engage an experienced civil litigation solicitor if you plan to challenge a liquidation stay. If the case is not ‘genuinely arguable’ is likely to be instantly dismissed. Even if this threshold is passed, the court retains the discretion to do what it believes is just and fair in the particular case.

Situations in which the court may allow litigation against an insolvent company include if:

  • the insolvency has been going on for some time
  • court proceedings would assist in clarifying a complex issue related to the insolvency
  • there are a large number of claimants

It is important to note that even if a liquidation stay is lifted, the court can state that a judgment cannot be enforced against the company without a further court order.

In summary

If you are an unsecured creditor of a large organisation which has fallen into liquidation, it is crucial you seek professional advice to discover your position. Failure to do so could see your business suffer greatly and perhaps meet the same fate.

Saracens Solicitors is a multi-service law firm based in London’s West End. We have dedicated and highly experienced civil litigation solicitors who can advise you on all civil litigation matters. For more information, please call our office on 020 3588 3500.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/oct/07/collapse-monarch-last-days-doomed-airline

[2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2018/01/15/carillion-could-owe-supply-chain-1bn-30000-businesses-face-financial/

[3] https://www.theguardian.com/business/live/2018/jan/16/uk-inflation-cpi-poud-carillion-collapse-fallout-business-live?page=with:block-5a5dbb74e4b0cb50d297207f#block-5a5dbb74e4b0cb50d297207f

[4] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-42695661

[5] Ibid

Continue Reading

Is Mediation Compulsory in England and Wales? Court-Ordered Mediation Explained (2026)

Written by Amani Mahmoud, Foreign Qualified Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 15 October 2026 When Is Mediation Compulsory in England and Wales? Short answer: While there is no general law making mediation compulsory in every civil claim, in practice it is close to mandatory. Since October 2024, the courts can order parties to […]

Ending a Tenancy Without Court Proceedings: The Deed of Surrender Explained

Written by Maxim Sealey, Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 28 September 2026   A deed of surrender is a formal legal document, signed by both landlord and tenant, that brings a tenancy to an end by agreement and confirms the tenant has no further rights to occupy the property, without the landlord needing […]

Can a Disputed Debt Stop a Winding-Up Petition? What Company Directors Need to Know

Written by Maxim Sealey, Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 28 September 2026   Disputing the exact amount of a debt is generally not enough on its own to stop a company from being wound up. To successfully halt liquidation proceedings, a company must show that liability for the debt itself is genuinely disputed […]

Unfair Prejudice Petitions: Why There’s No Time Limit to Bring a Claim

Written by Maxim Sealey, Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 24 September 2026   Unfair prejudice petitions are unusual in English litigation because there is no statutory limitation period restricting when a shareholder can bring one, unlike almost every other civil claim, which must generally be issued within a fixed number of years of […]

Section 8 Possession Notice: Form 3A Guide for Landlords

Written by Maxim Sealey, Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 24 September 2026   Form 3A is now the prescribed notice landlords must use to begin possession proceedings under section 8 of the Housing Act 1988, and it has replaced the previous Form 3 with immediate effect. If you or your managing agent have […]

Do I Have to Go to Court? Mediation & Dispute Resolution Explained

Written by Amani Mahmoud, Foreign Qualified Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 1 September 2026 Most Civil Disputes Settle Before Trial If you have watched A Few Good Men, Suits or Legally Blonde, you might assume that every legal dispute ends with a dramatic courtroom showdown. However, the reality is very different. If you […]

Why Monthly Rent Payments Help Landlords Evict Faster Under Section 8

Written by Maxim Sealey, Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 24 August 2026   Setting rent to be payable monthly, rather than quarterly or at another longer interval, gives landlords a meaningfully faster route to eviction under section 8 of the Housing Act 1988 for rent arrears. This is because the mandatory ground for […]

Transfer Possession Order to High Court for Faster Eviction Enforcement

Written by Maxim Sealey, Associate Solicitor · SRA-regulated · Last reviewed 10 August 2026   If you already have a possession order but the county court’s bailiffs are taking months to enforce it, you can apply to transfer enforcement of that order to the High Court, where enforcement officers typically act far more quickly, often […]

ESG Disputes: Can You Be Sued for Your Supply Chain’s Carbon Footprint?

As we move through 2026, the era of “voluntary” sustainability reporting has come to an abrupt end. Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) criteria have transitioned from marketing slogans to hard legal obligations. For directors and legal teams, the most significant shift isn’t what is happening within their own four walls—it is what is happening miles […]

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

Name